Free Pdf The Bone Woman: A Forensic Anthropologist's Search for Truth in the Mass Graves of Rwanda, Bosnia, Croatia, and KosovoAuthor Clea Koff – Bilb-weil.de

I was expecting to invalidate a lot of the complaints about Clea Koff s book, but I wasanddisappointed as the book progressed Gone was the wisdom of her experience, missing was the self discovery and introspection, only barely existent was her experience of the people around her who had survived the horrors, and the writing that replaced what had begun to glimmer in the first few chapters was that of a hardened, unhappy woman who seemed stressed out and angry at her coworkers This I was expecting to invalidate a lot of the complaints about Clea Koff s book, but I wasanddisappointed as the book progressed Gone was the wisdom of her experience, missing was the self discovery and introspection, only barely existent was her experience of the people around her who had survived the horrors, and the writing that replaced what had begun to glimmer in the first few chapters was that of a hardened, unhappy woman who seemed stressed out and angry at her coworkers This does not mean that the book was completely worthless to me, and for that reason I give it three stars I think it is an extremely important book, one that examines one step of the process by which someone guilty of genocide comes to justice, and one that pays ample tribute to the remains of the people who cry out for justice I hope Clea has foundpeace, both with her coworkers and with herself, in the four years since the last part of the book I did feel as though I was there, experiencing every part of it with her, and she did an ample job of keeping the jargon of her profession to a manageable level which was something that had worried me prior to reading the book She really is a wonderful writer on the face of it, but just needed to focus a bit less on the problems that happened within each mission Actual Rating 3.5 Stars In , Rwanda was the scene of the first acts since World War II to be legally defined as genocide Two years later, Clea Koff, a twenty three year old forensic anthropologist, left the safe confines of a lab in Berkeley, California, to serve as one of sixteen scientists chosen by the United Nations to unearth the physical evidence of the Rwandan genocide Over the next four years, Koff s grueling investigations took her across geography synonymous with some of the worst crimes of the twentieth century The Bone Woman is Koff s unflinching, riveting account of her seven UN missions to Bosnia, Croatia, Kosovo, and Rwanda, as she shares what she saw, how it affected her, who was prosecuted based on evidence she found, and what she learned about the world Yet even as she recounts the hellish nature of her work and the heartbreak of the survivors, she imbues her story with purpose, humanity, and a sense of justice A tale of science in service of human rights, The Bone Woman is, even profoundly, a story of hope and enduring moral principles Some intereesting passages, but mechanically written The distance that Koff needed to maintain between her job exhuming mass graves and her interior self has been preserved in her writing. The experiences of a forensic anthropologist working for ICTY and ICTR described in a very personal manner I felt strangely relieved seeing thah we had both asked ourselves the same question what if I had been in the middle of all that killing and destruction Still wondering about the answer though Everyone could benefit by reading this book. When you have completed a case and turned in your paperwork, you may still be thinking about it But before that thinking takes you to a place where you realize that this case was just like the one you had before and maybe just like one from Kigali, before you notice that the case file says that your last case was the husband of the old woman being analyzed at the next table, and before you think about that or feel the sadness, you are assigned your next case and the pathologist is in a hurry an When you have completed a case and turned in your paperwork, you may still be thinking about it But before that thinking takes you to a place where you realize that this case was just like the one you had before and maybe just like one from Kigali, before you notice that the case file says that your last case was the husband of the old woman being analyzed at the next table, and before you think about that or feel the sadness, you are assigned your next case and the pathologist is in a hurry and wants to get it done before lunch Snap You are saved from thinking and feeling until later, maybe much later, after you have left the mission and you find yourself crying into your pillow twelve thousand kilometers away, a world away, with your hands that touched and your mind that remembers and that elderly husband and wife are still dead, and you know the finality of that and you are left thinking and feeling indefinitely.I loved this one It s so refreshing to read about another woman s experience on the field, especially when it comes to things like feelings, hygiene gasp periods , harassment, and above all dealing with the grief and sometimes straight up denial of family members whose loved ones have been brutally massacred I m not saying it s the norm, but male anthropologists tend to not give thosehuman aspects the relevance they deserve An excellent book by an extraordinary young woman who has worked in the remains of the human abattoirs around the world Rwanda, Kosovo, Croatia, all needed the services of a team of forensic scientists to figure out the identities of the bodies all decayed, many reduced to piles of bones and to ascertain if those people died as a result of crimes against humanity Koff and her associates had to show how these people had died and to make sure they weren t causalities of civil war or revolution An excellent book by an extraordinary young woman who has worked in the remains of the human abattoirs around the world Rwanda, Kosovo, Croatia, all needed the services of a team of forensic scientists to figure out the identities of the bodies all decayed, many reduced to piles of bones and to ascertain if those people died as a result of crimes against humanity Koff and her associates had to show how these people had died and to make sure they weren t causalities of civil war or revolutionary uprisings Even though they lived in primitive conditions no running water in Rwanda, cold water for in the taps for two hours per day in Bosnia for example were subject to the strictures of the infamous United Nations bureaucracy and were often in the middle of a hostile population that didn t want them to succeed, Koff and her associates came up with the evidence to try and in most cases convict those who gave the order for mass murder Each chapter is a new deployment to areas containing mass graves Koff begins with a short and even handed account of the massacres and the events just before them and then gets down to the work itself, uncovering human remains work that is both exhausting and painstaking They are scientists digging in the dirt with picks and shovels then brushing away what sticks to the bones with the finest tiny brushes Koff herself has quite a background Her father is English, her mother Tanzanian They are documentary filmmakers who packed up the family Clea and her brother and took them to Africa, the Middle East and South America while they were filming With an undergrad degree from Stanford and graduate study at Arizona, she was asked to take part in the first forensic mission to Rwanda when she was 23 years old She describes how she loses her scientific detachment when she gets what she calls double vision , seeing beyond the skeleton in front of her to the person that it might once have been for example a preteen boy who has been shot in the head One of the most gruesome discoveries in Rwanda happened when they began finding ankle bones with machete slashes When the killers simply had too much work to do too many people to kill they would severe a victim s Achilles tendons so they he couldn t run away and would be there for killing hours or even days later One mass grave in Croatia was full of the staff and patients from a hospital, some of the patients with plaster casts on limbs or with IV needles still in their arms Highly recommended This is the second time I have read this book a book I found enjoyable both times I read it Many of the reviews have complained it was not professional however this is exactly the thing I enjoyed about it The distancing that can occur to produce self preservation is balanced here by Ms Koff s candor about when those distances are reduced and emotional breakdown occurs I would like to have hearddetail about the places they stayed and other members of the crew Learningabout th This is the second time I have read this book a book I found enjoyable both times I read it Many of the reviews have complained it was not professional however this is exactly the thing I enjoyed about it The distancing that can occur to produce self preservation is balanced here by Ms Koff s candor about when those distances are reduced and emotional breakdown occurs I would like to have hearddetail about the places they stayed and other members of the crew Learningabout the local groups would also have been an improvement but all in all, I enjoyed the book I don t know that I would read it a third time, but will use it as a teaching tool if the need arises Koff occasionally gets a little too much of her own personal journey in the pages for my taste, but at other points I find her personal reflections particularly relevant Mostly when she overshares and gets off on personal meditations, I m willing to forgive her because the rest of it is so interesting.The inside view into both the fieldwork and the morgue at a handful of ICT sites in Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia is fascinating Koff shares the realities of her chosen work, warts and all th Koff occasionally gets a little too much of her own personal journey in the pages for my taste, but at other points I find her personal reflections particularly relevant Mostly when she overshares and gets off on personal meditations, I m willing to forgive her because the rest of it is so interesting.The inside view into both the fieldwork and the morgue at a handful of ICT sites in Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia is fascinating Koff shares the realities of her chosen work, warts and all the lack of appropriate and functional equipment and timely training on UN and ICT missions, the involved process of unearthing bodies that are jumbled together in mass graves and don t always fit into neat archaeological levels, the numerous methods of physically identifying bodies, the strange pressures of living amongst the relatives of the bodies being unearthed, and the tough physical and emotional demands and the interpersonal effects of sharing tight quarters with co workers experiencing the same pressures I think I most appreciated towards the end when Koff becomes part of the team in charge of a mission, and is able to see some of the effects of her work come full circle bodies she helped to take out of the ground when she was in the field are returned to their families for reburial A sense of the general flow of the bodies being exhumed gender and age breakdowns, couples and families buried together It s also interesting when she s able to make cross connections between sites in Rwanda and Bosnia worth considering the implications of similarities between what might be understood as vastly different events Do the graves tell similar stories I flirted really hard with the idea of pursuing forensic anthropology when I was an anthro and poli sci undergrad Not sure I should ve gone that way, but reading this really makes me itch to be in a plastic suit in a mass grave, bringing out those murdered and helping justice finally be served The Bone Woman is an incredibly well written and poignant book written by the forensic anthropologist Clea Koff The author talks about her work on mass graves in Rwanda, Bosnia and Kosovo as part of UN International Criminal Tribunal investigations.It is hard to describe this book I feel like I have undertaken a very long and exhausting journey Ms Koff described her surroundings so well I feel as if I actually visited hot, leafy forests in Rwanda and cold, grey landscapes in the Balkans The The Bone Woman is an incredibly well written and poignant book written by the forensic anthropologist Clea Koff The author talks about her work on mass graves in Rwanda, Bosnia and Kosovo as part of UN International Criminal Tribunal investigations.It is hard to describe this book I feel like I have undertaken a very long and exhausting journey Ms Koff described her surroundings so well I feel as if I actually visited hot, leafy forests in Rwanda and cold, grey landscapes in the Balkans There were times when I had to put this book down and simply process the information that I was reading.There is something about the human condition whereby we find it hard to imagine mass murder we find it hard to comprehend the mechanics of taking the life of hundreds of people in one event we find it hard to imagine that these were once people, to put a human face to the atrocity In her book, Clea Koff does this for us she paints a picture whereby the reader is finally able to comprehend and understand